Yes, I think it’s better since we should not use direct app login from Gitlab anymore and only use SAML through the Keycloak.
Well, please read the previous conversation, and understand why it’s not acceptable for us to make visible a link to Microsoft. Since all 3 ‘acceptable’ identity providers accept GH logins, there’s no reason why we should not support them instead of Microsoft.
Being anarchist does not preclude having different strategies. Probably the Dutch AF has no serious sysadmin in their ranks and prefer to adopt a Marxist approach to gather a critical mass – hahaha. More seriously, what they do does not concern us.
Rather the opposite: librehosters were created as a political response to the GMAFIA oligarchy, so the position is political from day one.
Our strategy is to make visible what alternatives exist, not to support the enemy. If we say the enemy is the GMAFIA, then we do not make them visible. Supporting our friends makes much more sense, hence the will to put into visibility Framagit, Git Coop (and to a lesser extent, Gitlab, since it gathered most of the GH diaspora, despite being VC-funded core business, it remains the most serious global scale alternative to GH, until it is acquired by some other giant).
It should appear obvious to each of us that making our friends visible is a viable tactic, while making the enemy visible is suicidal since the latter don’t need us to be visible as they’re the masters already, aren’t they?
I’m always puzzled at people who think that it’s good to “degooglize” Internet, but it’s OK to use GMAFIA clouds.